Cruise Ships/Floating Cities
Cruise Ship Pollution: Background,
Laws and Regulations Key Issues
Updated June 14, 2007
GAO CRS Report for Congress
Cruise ships carrying several thousand passengers and crew
have been compared to "floating cities," in part because the volume of wastes
produced and requiring disposal is greater than that of many small cities on land.
During a typical one-week voyage, a large cruise ship (with 3,000 passengers and
crew) is estimated to generate 210,000 gallons of sewage; 1 million gallons of
graywater (wastewater from sinks, showers, and laundries); more than 130 gallons
of hazardous wastes; 8 tons of solid waste; and 25,000 gallons of oily bilge water.
Cruise Ship Pollution 2007 GAO Report
In 2000, a coalition of 53 environmental advocacy groups petitioned the
Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) to take regulatory action to address
pollution by cruise ships. The petition called for an investigation of wastewater, oil,
and solid waste discharges from cruise ships. In response, EPA agreed to study
cruise ship discharges and waste management approaches. As part of that effort, in
2000 EPA issued a background document with preliminary information and
recommendations for further assessment through data collection and public
information hearings. The agency reportedly is developing a cruise ship discharge
assessment report that may be released in the fall of 2007, but it has not made a final
decision on the environmental groups’ original petition, which has been pending for
seven years. In May 2007 the groups sued EPA, seeking to compel the agency to
act on the petition.
In 2000, Congress enacted legislation restricting cruise ship discharges in U.S.
navigable waters within the state of Alaska.
As of January
2005, passenger ships (which include cruise ships and ferries) composed about 12%
of the world shipping fleet.1 The cruise industry is a significant and growing
contributor to the U.S. economy, providing more than $32 billion in total benefits
annually and generating more than 330,000 U.S. jobs, but also making the
environmental impacts of its activities an issue to many. Since 1980, the average
annual growth rate in the number of cruise passengers worldwide has been 8.4%, and
in 2005, cruises hosted an estimated 11.5 million passengers. Cruises are especially
popular in the United States. In 2005, U.S. ports handled 8.6 million cruise
embarkations (75% of global passengers), 6.3% more than in 2004. The worldwide
cruise ship fleet consists of more than 230 ships, and the majority are foreignflagged,
with Liberia and Panama being the most popular flag countries.3 Foreignflag
cruise vessels owned by six companies account for nearly 95% of passenger
ships operating in U.S. waters. Each year, the industry adds new ships to the total
fleet (12 new cruise ships debuted in 2004 and 4 more in 2005), vessels that are
bigger, more elaborate and luxurious, and that carry larger numbers of passengers and
crew.
California enacted three bills in 2004. One bars cruise ships from discharging
treated wastewater while in the state’s waters (Calif. A.B. 2672). Another prohbits
vessels from releasing graywater (Calif. A.B. 2093), and the third measure prevents
cruise ships from operating waste incinerators (Calif. A.B. 471). Additionally, in
2003 California enacted a law that bans passenger ships from discharging sewage
sludge and oil bilge water (Calif. A.B. 121), as well as a bill that prohibits vessels
from discharging hazardous wastes from photo-processing and dry cleaning
operations into state waters (Calif. A.B. 906). Another measure was enacted in 2006:
California S.B. 497 requires the state to adopt ballast water performance standards
by January 2008 and sets specific deadlines for the removal of different types of
species from ballast water, mandating that ship operators remove invasive species
(including bacteria) by the year 2020.
|